The Power Of Substack On Journalism

Substack had its issues in the past with platforming Neo Nazi viewpoints. Lots of people fled the platform when they found out. But people's memories are fleeting and many mainstream journalists are starting to setup their newsletters on Substack. Heck, even the term Substack is becoming synonymous with the term newsletter like how the term Google is with synonymous with searching the Web.

I've gotten into disagreements with journalist, who I have immense respect for, over using Substack for their newsletter system. And some make decent points.

Famed technology journalist and former reporter for the New York Times and the Washington post, Taylor Lorenz has said Substack enabled her to start her newsletter, UserMag, easily and freely (obviously sans the platform's percentage take of the paid subscriber fees). She's gotten blow back on social media for her choice.

Mike Elgan, another well known technology journalist, podcaster, and pundit, who I really enjoy, and often agree with, disagreed with me that Substack is bad and should be avoided.

I asked for his thoughts on this piece:

I agree with Mike to an extent, here. If it's legal it should be allowed and people can vote with their wallets, but what concerns me is that so many journalist are escaping the traditional journalism apparatus and setting up shop on Substack, with what I suspect, not knowing if it's the right place for them. It's more an exercise in being a "Lemming."

Yes, you can export your content and move it to another platform. And, yes you can move your list. But with the viral nature of the platform many people are blinded by the shiny object and also not realizing that they are giving up 10% or more of their membership revenue to Substack if they charge for their content.

I'm torn with the idea of Substack. I first started this newsletter there, then moved it to a self-hosted and custom WordPress solution, finally landing on the Ghost CMS.

I know of a few popular writers who moved off of Substack when the whole "platforming of Nazis" happened. That's when I jumped ship as well.

Many of these ex-Substackers are happy with their move to other platforms. I know Casey Newton, of the Platformer.news newsletter, who moved to Ghost has said publicly that he's happy with the move. Ryan Broderick of the Garbage Day newsletter moved to Beehiiv and has said that he's happy he did that move as well.

I like the idea of the social-nature of Substack, but with their hockey stick growth and "EVERYONE" flocking to put their newsletters there, I fear a potential lock down of content at some point. Hell, I'm probably crazy. But, I can't help but be concerned.

Ultimately, it's personal choice on both sides. If you like the writer–support them. If you're not thrilled with the service–vote with you wallet.

What do you think am I nuts? Or am I on to something? Let me know!

The Latest From The Entrepreneur's Enigma Podcast

The Latest From Digital Marketing Dive

Why Posting On Social Media Is Important, But The Engagement Is Even More Important

Welcome back to Digital Marketing Dive! In this episode, hosts Seth Goldstein and Brian Griffiths dig into a topic that every business and marketer needs to hear: w…

Digital Marketing DiveDigital Marketing Dive

Sponsor/Affiliate Plug

Looking for guests? Want to be on podcasts? Check out Podmatch! I use it for both getting on podcasts and finding quality guests. It's well worth it and affordable too!

Web Jawn

What the actual f*ck?! How is this a good thing? What could possibly go wrong? A LOT! 😖🙄🤔

Zuckerberg Says in Response to Loneliness Epidemic, He Will Create Most of Your Friends Using Artificial Intelligence

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg is more concerned about his billions of customers making friends with AI chatbots than creating bonds with real human beings.

FuturismVictor Tangermann

Can he be anymore of a loser? Geezus

The hammer falls on Apple’s malicious-compliance scheme

Tim Cook specifically approved enhanced “scare screen” language, according to the court ruling. U.S. District Court judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled largely in Apple’s favor in …

Six Colors

Apple got caught with its hand in the cookie jar.

Google credits Gemini for better detection of fake business reviews and maps spam

Google took down over 240 million policy-violating reviews from 2024, that’s 40% more than the previous year.

Search Engine LandBarry Schwartz

This is good news for AI and Gemini helping get rid of fake business reviews.

Pinterest launches new tools to fight AI slop | TechCrunch

Pinterest says it’s finally going to do something about the AI slop that’s taken over its platform. After an increasing volume of complaints, the social

TechCrunchSarah Perez

AI slop is everywhere, I wonder if Pinterst's tools will be successful.

AI Is Nothing Like a Brain, and That’s OK | Quanta Magazine

The brain’s astounding cellular diversity and networked complexity could show how to make AI better.

Quanta MagazineYasemin Saplakoglu

An interesting piece.

Is Chrome Even a Sellable Asset?

It’s hard to come up with a buyer who could afford to pay a high price for Chrome and who would pass regulatory muster as its new owner. And if Chrome is not worth a high price, or simply isn’t sellable at one, then why is the DOJ trying to force Google to sell it? They might as well try to force Google to sell the two o’s from its name.

Daring Fireball

I'm not so sure it is. But I think it should be given to a non-profit to manage.

The Smart TV Factor: What Growing Connected TV Listening Means for Podcasting - Sounds Profitable

Smart TVs are increasingly popular tools for accessing podcasts, but what does that actually mean for the medium?

Sounds Profitable - The business of podcastingTom Webster

People, it seems, actually watch/listen to podcasts on their smart televisions! I'm not one of them, but that's just me. What Tom points out is don't assume that it's all video being consumed this way and don't ignore the 55+ listeners.

From Audio to Video, Spotify’s $100 Million Payout Fuels Creator Success Stories — Spotify

Podcasts have become a cornerstone of the Spotify experience, evolving from a niche interest to a cultural phenomenon. As the format continues to grow, we’re seeing an exciting trend emerge: the rise of video podcasts. At Spotify, we’re committed to supporting creators across all formats, and we’re thrilled to announce a significant milestone in that…

SpotifyAurelie.Corinthiosgroupsjr.com

Keep in mind this is pretty much a press release from Spotify and the majority of the money is through the Spotify partner program. So take what's here with a grain of salt. Still people are making something with podcasting and advertising.

Sundar Pichai warns of ‘extraordinary’ risk to Google Search

Alphabet’s CEO said the DOJ antitrust remedies could dismantle Search, threaten privacy, and reshape how billions interact with the web.

Search Engine LandDanny Goodwin

Of course he warns this, because it will hurt Google. Kind of obvious.

Want to beat AI Overviews? Produce unmistakably human content

Identify content topics where readers want to hear from people – and leave no doubt that they’re hearing from people.

Search Engine LandFrank Olivo

Spot on and solid tip. Kind of a "duh."

Google’s NotebookLM Android and iOS apps are available for preorder | TechCrunch

Google’s NotebookLM Android and iOS apps are expected to launch on May 20, according to app store listings. The apps are currently available for preorder.

TechCrunchAisha Malik

NotebookLM is a really nifty for research. I'm excited to see it come to mobile!

Apple changes US App Store rules to let apps link to external payment systems | TechCrunch

Apple has changed its App Store rules in the U.S. to let apps link users to their own websites so they can buy subscriptions or other digital goods. This

TechCrunchIvan Mehta

This is big news.

Hidden costs in AI deployment: Why Claude models may be 20-30% more expensive than GPT in enterprise settings

It is a well-known fact that different model families can use different tokenizers. However, there has been limited analysis on how the process of “tokenization” itself varies across these tokenizers. Do all tokenizers result in the same number of tokens for a given input text? If not, how different are the generated tokens? How significant […]

VentureBeatLavanya Gupta

Yep. And the price of AI is only going to go up.

Facebook Announces New Measures to Combat Spam Posts and Comments

Facebook is looking to crack down on hashtag overuse and other issues.

Social Media TodayAndrew Hutchinson

Spam is the bane of all of everyone. It'll be interesting to see if Meta is able to quash some.

xAI Dev Leaks API Key for Private SpaceX, Tesla LLMs

A employee at Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence company xAI leaked a private key on GitHub that for the past two months could have allowed anyone to query private xAI large language models (LLMs) which appear to have been custom made for…

Krebs on SecuritySkip to content

Quality code over at xAI. Geezus.

Mark Zuckerberg Thinks You Don’t Have Enough Friends and His Chatbots Are the Answer

The CEO of Meta says “the average American has fewer than three friends, fewer than three people they would consider friends. And the average person has demand for meaningfully more.”

404 MediaSamantha Cole

Exactly what I want to do is be friends with Zuck's bots. I can't think of anything worse!

WordPress Leadership Reinstates 32 Banned WordPress.org Accounts, Launches Formal Review

WordPress project leadership has reinstated 32 WordPress.org accounts and launched a formal review into dozens more Slack accounts, following ongoing concerns about how account bans have been handled on WordPress.org and Slack.

The RepositoryRae Morey

This is a good move and hopefully will repair the relationship between WordPress and the user base.

Matt Mullenweg Reverses Course on Blocking Accounts and Banning Contributors in Surprise ‘WordPress Jubilee’

WordPress co-founder walks back months of bans, citing personal reflection and the Catholic Jubilee tradition.

The RepositoryRae Morey

I wonder if there is something behind the scenes that made this happen.

A Hacker’s Perspective on WordPress Security – Q&A with Mat Rollings (Stealthcopter) - Patchstack

Hear from an ethical hacker, Mat Rollings AKA Stealthcopter, on the best practices for WordPress security!

PatchstackLana Rafaela

Worth a read/watch (it's video interview with a transcript).

An Interview with Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg About AI and the Evolution of Social Media

An interview with Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg about Llama and the AI opportunity, the evolution of social medial, and what it means to connect.

Stratechery by Ben Thompson

This was an interesting interview. Worth, at least, reading through the transcript.

AI is getting “creepy good” at geo-guessing

After hearing about ChatGPT o3 ability at geo-guessing we decided to run some tests and the tested AIs didn’t fail to amaze us

MalwarebytesPieter Arntz

Of course AI is creepy. Just now we have proof of guessing where we're located.

Is it safe? Does Google’s evolving view of auto-translated content, and lack of action with Reddit’s AI translations, open the floodgates for site owners?

Glenn Gabe covers Google’s evolving view of auto-translated content, including using AI to translate content at scale (based on Reddit’s heavy use of AI-translations).

The Internet Marketing DriverGlenn Gabe

This is a MUST read!

🎙️Podcast Coaching 🎙️

I've been podcasting since 2010. During those 12+ years I've learned a thing or two about the ins and outs of the industry and approaching it the right way.

I've decided to offer podcast coaching as a service to share the knowledge that I've accumulated over the decade-plus in the industry.

More information click here.

Web Find

Generative Engine Optimization (GEO): The Future of AI-Driven Search

Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) is rapidly emerging as a crucial strategy in the age of AI-driven search. As search engines integrate generative AI – from chatbots like ChatGPT and Bing Chat to Google’s Search Generative Experience (SGE) – the rules of traditional SEO are being rewritten.

LinkedInJarrod Anderson

A great run down on Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) from Jarrod Anderson over on LinkedIn Pulse.

Finally, earbuds built for podcast junkies not music snobs - Yanko Design

https://youtu.be/YwlGLWiyfFc You know how audiophiles get their own specialist gear? Music equipment specifically tuned to the needs of hi-fidelity audio? Gamers get their own specialist gear too. Low-latency audio solutions, with mics, controls, the works. What about podcast listeners? Can you think of how audio gear would look if it were specifically designed for people

Yanko DesignSarang Sheth

What a neat concept for earbuds, geared for the podcaster junkie, not the music lover.

The SHEQONOMI podcast APPS powered by women targeting the bottom billion on Android, iOS, KaiOS, Cloudphone and JiO devices. Check it out! There is a large directory of awesome podcasts in tons of different languages and dialects.

That's It For This Week! Keep Rocking It!

-Seth

Thanks for reading! If you're liking the newsletter and the content that I curate, please consider signing up for a pay-what-you-want subscription to help me continue to write this weekly newsletter.