Podcasting Is Not Going To Lead To Direct ROI

I've been podcasting for more than 15 years. I'll be honest, I've never gotten direct ROI from the podcasting. You need to think about it differently.

Podcasting Is Not Going To Lead To Direct ROI
Photo by Hc Digital / Unsplash

I've been podcasting for more than a decade and none of it has produced direct income/ROI for me. What it has done is much more valuable. Don't let this discourage you.

Podcasting has enabled me to build up a personal brand, build out a new division of Goldstein Media, Podcast Mastery, and indirectly HAS led to ROI.

I do get some revenue, albeit a very small amount, from the advertising that's on my two podcasts from the Marketing Podcast Network. But that might be $100 a month if that.

But, honestly, I'm not doing my Entrepreneur's Enigma and Digital Marketing Dive podcasts for the direct ROI, I'm doing them for the chance to be a subject matter expert. And in that way I've succeeded.

I've had to break it to my clients that they're not going to be the next Joe Rogan or Mel Robbins. Those two had built in audiences from their TV shows and for being really well known across many different verticals.

So I burst that bubble as quickly as I can when I'm working with my clients. It's important to set expectations.

If you have 300 quality listeners every month to your show and they engage with you regularly, that's 100 times better than having double or triple that don't engage.

The best way to capitalize on your podcast is to have a plan in place on how you're going to sustain it. Both with your energy and budget. Having a clear plan is key to becoming an "established podcaster." I put that in quotes because to be established there is an arbitrary threshold of 100+ episodes and/or 2 years putting out shows. Who came up with that metric and why, I'm not sure.

But I digress. *Don't act surprised 😏😉

You need to think outside-the-box when it comes to getting more value out of your show. Here's three ideas that I see podcasters using to get ROI from their show:

  1. Start a community - Don't start with it being paid, but build it out, get people talking and engaging, then offer paid for bonus, like master classes or 1-on-1 sessions with you.
  2. Launch a Patreon - Don't start this at the beginning of your journey. But a ways in you can see how engaged your listeners are and offer perks to becoming a patron.
  3. Offer a special service to your listeners - Something that is in your wheelhouse that is exclusive to your audience.

In the end don't try and monetize your show thinking that you're going to be rich. Because you'll be setting yourself up for disappointment. Think outside the box and most of all HAVE FUN.


🎙️
Interested in learning from my 15 years of podcast experience and want to be in a vibrant community of like-minded podcasters and podcast guests? Check out the PodcastMastery.Community for more information!

The Latest From The Entrepreneur's Enigma Podcast

https://entrepreneursenigma.com/alexsanfilippo

Looking for guests? Want to be on podcasts? Check out Podmatch! I use it for both getting on podcasts and finding quality guests. It's well worth it and affordable too!


💲
Want To Sponsor The Newsletter? Reach 1,250+ subscribers weekly who are in the marketing industry. Hit reply to this email and let's have a chat!

Web Jawn

How The Ottawa Hospital uses AI ambient voice capture to reduce physician burnout by 70%, achieve 97% patient satisfaction
TOH is using Microsoft’s DAX Copilot to capture physician-patient conversations and generate draft clinical notes in real time.

A good use for AI in medicine.

LinkedIn wants to make job hunting suck less with new AI tools
LinkedIn knows looking for jobs sucks. So it added some new AI tools to help users find work and help them prepare for interviews.

This is another good use for AI if it works correctly.

Mastodon: Giving Journalists Options Away From Big Tech - We Distribute
At the International Journalism Festival, Mastodon joined forces with Save Social to make a case for journalists and publications to join the network.

Mastodon and journalism FTW.

Cloudflare CEO: AI is killing the business model of the web
Google’s value exchange with content creators has collapsed – and the web’s business model is cracking, according to Matthew Prince.

Then on the flip side, AI isn't sending traffic to sites as much any more especially through Google and it's Gemini AI. “Today, 75 percent of the queries… get answered without you leaving Google,” Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince says.

How ChatGPT search ranks products and merchants
ChatGPT’s search shopping features are here. Here’s what we know about how product results are selected and results are displayed and ranked.

Can't beat AI, learn how to live with it and get it to work for you.

Meta Outlines Facebook, Instagram and Threads Ad Updates at Newfronts 2025
A range of new Meta ad updates to consider.

New updates from Meta. These might be compelling but Meta is still a very icky company if you ask me.

YouTube Outlines Advanced Creator Collaboration Tools at Newfronts 2025
Some new tools to help brands find relevant YouTube creators to work with.

This could be interesting.

Florida bill requiring encryption backdoors for social media accounts has failed | TechCrunch
The bill would have required social media companies create encryption backdoors to allow access to users’ private information.

This is great news!

Why Apple is trying to save Google
On The Vergecast: Antitrust antics, the new Surfaces, and Netflix goes TikTok.

It's all about the $$$$$$$! Not one bit altruistic. 🙄

Patreon will update its iPhone app to sidestep Apple’s payment system
“This is a huge moment for creators and their businesses.”

This is good news. More money for the creators.

The Great Podcast Divide: Understanding Fans vs. Anti-Fans - Sounds Profitable
A look at the demographics of podcast audiences who are the medium’s fans… as well as the opposite.

Tom Webster, of Sounds Profitable, always has good insights.

Google’s Updated Raters Guidelines Target Fake EEAT Content
Google’s updated QRG now includes fake EEAT content and other deceptive practices, signaling the importance of authenticity

Don't be putting out fake content and you'll be fine. 🤔😁😉

Perplexity AI’s quiet coup
Perplexity managed to use Apple’s own APIs to supersede Siri, Google and everyone else as the iPhone’s best place to get information.

Perplexity is a force to be reckoned with.

Toxic Users: The Unforgiven and the Danger of Unbanning - Half-Elf on Tech
Toxic users can poison an online community. They harass, threaten, and exploit. Some are beyond redemption. This is why unbanning the unforgiven is a dangerous gamble.

Mika Epstein makes some good points that unbanning people in the WordPress ecosystem can't be done in bulk. Some bans need to stick for safety reasons. Matt Mullenweg really make a mess of everything, IMHO. 😖🙄🤔

Figma releases new AI-powered tools for creating sites, app prototypes, and marketing assets | TechCrunch
Design company Figma today announced multiple features, including AI-powered site and web app creation, a way for marketers to create assets in bulk, and

This Figma tool looks really cool! Wish it would tie in easier with WordPress, but still very cool.

Consumer reliance on AI search results signals new era of marketing – Bain & Company

AI search is taking over. Some interesting and some worrisome stats in this report.

Going renewable, growing people, sharing knowledge – Our 2024 sustainability pulse
Our 2024 sustainability report highlights our transition to renewable energy, investment in people development, and commitment to knowledge sharing.

This is good news. I'm happy to hear this as a customer.

Nerding Out on SEO with Jono Alderson
Dive into a deep technical SEO nerd talk with Jono Alderson and Gianluca Fiorelli as they explore the SEO profession, its biases, EEAT, technical SEO, and more.

This looks like a great video deep dive with an expert in the SEO space.

Deepfakes, Scams, and the Age of Paranoia
As AI-driven fraud becomes increasingly common, more people feel the need to verify every interaction they have online.

A whole new world!

Figma Sites Isn’t the Future (Yet)—But It’s Coming for WordPress and Framer Anyway
Figma Sites just dropped, promising to kill WordPress and dethrone Framer — but under the glossy UI lies a half-baked toy, not a revolution. It might be the future of web design... just not today.

Half-baked but a start of something... maybe?


🎙️Podcast Coaching 🎙️

AI generated person podcasting
You've got questions. I've got the answers!

I've been podcasting since 2010. During those 12+ years I've learned a thing or two about the ins and outs of the industry and approaching it the right way.

I've decided to offer podcast coaching as a service to share the knowledge that I've accumulated over the decade-plus in the industry.

More information click here.


Web Finds And More Fun Stuff

‘I Loved That AI:’ Judge Moved by AI-Generated Avatar of Man Killed in Road Rage Incident
How the sister of Christopher Pelkey made an avatar of him to testify in court.

File this under the WTAF category. I have so many questions! This is such a strange thing. I'm not sure what to think about this. On one hand it's the sister's impact statement being read by AI as her brother. But on the other hand it's "reanimating" a dead person who can't have a say in their likeness being used.

How to add your podcast to every podcast directory
We have a daily podcast. Here’s where to find it - and all the directory links to add your podcast, too

Great tips from Mr. Podnews himself, James Cridland.

How to turn on Lockdown Mode for your iPhone and Mac
Extremely secure.

Good PSA for iPhone Users.

900 People Are Collectively Driving an ‘Internet Roadtrip’ on Google Street View
The new site is a cozy and chaotic sucessor to ’Twitch plays Pokémon.

This is what makes the Inter-Webs great!

Google tests replacing iconic ‘I’m Feeling Lucky’ with AI Mode button
Google is testing the removal of its iconic “I’m Feeling Lucky” button with a new AI Mode shortcut taking its place.

End of an era!


That's It For This Week! Keep Rocking It!

-Seth


Thanks for reading! If you're liking the newsletter and the content that I curate, please consider signing up for a pay-what-you-want subscription to help me continue to write this weekly newsletter.